Small-Dollar Lending That Actually Helps Members

Most credit unions are losing members to predatory lenders over amounts smaller than a car payment.

A $600 emergency, a $400 medical bill, a $900 car repair—those are the moments that quietly decide whether a member stays loyal to their credit union or walks into a payday storefront. In 2024, roughly 40% of U.S. adults still say they’d struggle to cover a $400 emergency from savings. That’s the playing field.

Here’s the thing about small-dollar lending: your members already have access to it. The question is whether they get that access from you in a safe, dignified way—or from a lender that makes their situation worse.

This post builds off a CUInsight Network conversation with Seth Brickman, CEO of QCash Financial CUSO, and focuses on what actually works when credit unions use AI-enabled, relational underwriting to deliver small-dollar loans at scale.

We’ll break down:

• Why small-dollar lending is a strategic growth and member-wellbeing opportunity
• How relational underwriting and AI change the risk equation
• Practical steps to design a member-centric small-dollar lending program
• How credit unions can use these tools to protect members from predatory lenders while managing risk

Why Small-Dollar Lending Is a Strategic Priority, Not a Side Project

Small-dollar lending is where your “people helping people” philosophy meets hard economics.

When a member turns to a payday lender, three things usually happen:

1. They pay APRs that can exceed 300%.
2. Their overall financial health declines, which shows up as higher delinquencies and charge-offs across other relationships.
3. Trust in their primary financial institution erodes.

Credit unions often avoid this space because:

• Underwriting $300–$2,000 loans with traditional methods is too expensive.
• Staff time per loan doesn’t pencil out.
• Legacy risk models say “decline” for thin-file or low-credit-score members.

The reality? Small-dollar loans are a member-retention tool, not just a loan product.

Credit unions that offer automated, affordable small-dollar lending typically see:

• Higher primary financial institution (PFI) status: more direct deposits, more debit and credit card usage
• Increased loan pull-through on larger products later (auto, HELOC, mortgage)
• Stronger brand loyalty—members remember who helped them in a crisis

“Let’s make sure members have access to the help they need when they need it.” – Seth Brickman

That’s the bar. If your members have to think twice about whether you’ll help them in an emergency, you’ve already lost them emotionally.

How Relational Underwriting Uses Data Credit Scores Ignore

Relational underwriting flips the script from “Can this member pass a credit score threshold?” to “What does our relationship say about their likelihood to repay?”

Traditional underwriting looks mostly at:

• Credit score
• Debt-to-income ratio
• Credit history depth

That works for mortgages. It’s terrible for emergency loans, especially for:

• Young members
• Immigrants and newcomers with thin files
• Members with previous credit dings who are now stable

What Relational Underwriting Actually Uses

Relational underwriting systems (like QCash’s patented approach) ingest behavioral and relationship data you already have, such as:

• Tenure with the credit union
• Direct deposit consistency and recency
• Average balances over time (not just today’s snapshot)
• Account behaviors (NSFs, overdrafts, repayment history)
• Product mix and engagement patterns

Instead of saying, “This member has a 580 FICO, decline,” the system might say:

• Member has 6+ years of consistent direct deposit
• Rare NSFs over the past 12 months
• Consistent utility and rent payments observed via transaction history
• Prior small loan paid off on time

Result: approve a $1,000 small-dollar loan at a fair rate in seconds, without manual review.

Why AI Matters Here

AI isn’t there to replace your lending team; it’s there to:

• Score thousands of micro-signals that humans can’t efficiently weigh
• Automate instant decisions on low-balance loans 24/7
• Continuously learn from repayment performance to sharpen risk models

Most credit unions are sitting on years of transactional and relationship data that could support much higher approval rates with controlled loss levels. Relational underwriting is how you turn that data into real financial inclusion.

Designing a Member-Centric Small-Dollar Lending Program

A member-centric small-dollar program has three non-negotiables: speed, simplicity, and dignity. If any of those are missing, members go elsewhere.

1. Make It Truly Instant and Accessible

Members facing an emergency aren’t going to:

• Drive to a branch
• Print pay stubs
• Wait two business days for a decision

They’re on their phone, often in a parking lot or at a repair shop. Your program should allow them to:

• Apply via mobile banking in under 60 seconds
• Receive an instant decision powered by relational underwriting
• Get funds deposited directly into their account in real time

This isn’t “nice to have” UX—this is the competitive edge against payday lenders and buy now, pay later apps.

2. Keep Terms Clear, Fair, and Boring

A good small-dollar loan is boring in the best way:

• Transparent APR
• Clear term (often 6–24 months)
• No hidden fees
• Predictable payment amounts

Consider guardrails like:

• Capping maximum loan size based on relationship and income data
• Cooling-off periods between loans to avoid debt spirals
• Automatic payment options aligned with pay cycles

The goal is to provide a short bridge, not a long-term crutch.

3. Treat Small-Dollar Lending as an On-Ramp, Not an Endpoint

Smart credit unions use small-dollar loans as the first step into deeper financial wellness, not a standalone product.

You can:

• Trigger financial coaching outreach for members who use emergency loans repeatedly
• Offer follow-up products like credit-builder loans or secured cards
• Use insights from the loan (on-time vs. late payments) to personalize future offers

One simple play that works: after a member successfully repays an emergency loan, proactively invite them to set up an automated savings plan in the same payment amount. You already proved they can live without that cash; now it can start building their safety net.

Managing Risk Without Saying “No” by Default

You can expand approvals and still run a tight risk ship. The key is being precise, not conservative by habit.

Build Risk Tiers, Not a Binary Switch

Instead of a yes/no model based only on credit scores, design risk tiers that use relational underwriting output:

• Tier 1: Strong relationship and behavior — qualify for maximum small-dollar limits, lowest rate
• Tier 2: Moderate signals — lower limits, slightly higher rate, shorter term
• Tier 3: Higher risk — smaller emergency-only amounts, tighter terms, more education and follow-up

This lets you say “yes” more often, but in different, calibrated ways.

Automate Guardrails, Not Just Approvals

AI and automation shouldn’t just approve loans; they should also:

• Flag early signs of distress (missed payments, sudden income changes)
• Trigger proactive outreach or hardship options
• Adjust future offers based on real repayment performance

I’ve seen the best programs treat small-dollar lending as a living risk system, not a one-time product launch. The models are updated as loss data comes in, marketing is tuned, and education is refined.

Align Product Design With Mission

If you’re serious about financial inclusion, your small-dollar lending policy should explicitly address:

• Avoiding fee stacking and junk fees
• Respecting members’ dignity in collections and outreach
• Offering paths out of repeat borrowing (e.g., debt consolidation options)

Members can tell when a “helpful” product is quietly designed for fee extraction. That’s how you lose trust permanently.

The Role of AI in Member-Centric Banking for Credit Unions

AI for credit unions works best when it’s invisible to the member and invaluable to the institution. Small-dollar lending is a perfect use case.

Here’s what effective AI-powered programs usually share:

• Embedded in digital channels: The member just sees a fast, friendly experience in mobile or online banking.
• Respectful of cooperative values: Models are trained and governed with fairness in mind, and biased outcomes are monitored and corrected.
• Focused on outcomes, not hype: The success metrics are concrete—approval rates, loss rates, member retention, and financial health improvements.

From what Seth Brickman and others in this space are seeing, credit unions using relational underwriting and AI for small-dollar loans are:

• Approving more loans for members who’d usually be declined
• Keeping loss rates within planned ranges by using relationship data constraints
• Seeing stronger engagement from communities that traditional models underserve

This matters because many credit unions are searching for credible, member-centric ways to use AI. Small-dollar, emergency, and specialty lending is one of the cleanest places to start: well-bounded, measurable, and clearly aligned with your mission.

Getting Started: Practical Next Steps for Your Credit Union

If your credit union isn’t yet offering an automated small-dollar lending program—or if your current one is underused—here’s a straightforward path.

1. Audit the current state.

   • How many members are denied for low-balance requests each month?
   • What’s the average approval time for an emergency loan?
   • How many inbound calls or branch visits relate to “I just need a little help”?

2. Clarify success metrics up front.

   • Target approval rate
   • Loss-rate tolerance
   • Member satisfaction and digital adoption goals

3. Decide your data philosophy.

   • Are you ready to let relationship and behavioral data meaningfully influence decisions, not just credit score?
   • Who will own model governance and fairness oversight?

4. Choose or refine the tech stack.

   • API-driven integration into online and mobile banking
   • Automated decisioning using relational underwriting
   • Real-time funding capabilities

5. Design for communication and education.

   • Clear, plain-language product descriptions
   • Follow-up journeys that promote savings and financial health
   • Staff training so everyone understands how and why approvals might look different

6. Pilot, learn, and iterate.

   • Start with a well-defined pilot segment
   • Monitor approval patterns, losses, and member feedback monthly
   • Adjust limits, pricing, and rules based on actual data

The credit unions that win in 2025 won’t be the ones with the flashiest AI slide deck. They’ll be the ones whose members feel, very tangibly, “My credit union had my back when I needed help.”

That’s exactly what thoughtful small-dollar lending, powered by relational underwriting and AI, is built to do.

---

If your team is planning how to use AI for member-centric banking, start where it matters most: the moments when members are most financially vulnerable. Design small-dollar lending to be fast, fair, and rooted in your relationship data, and you’ll protect your members from predatory lenders while deepening loyalty for years.